Tracking error measures how much a portfolio's returns differ from its benchmark's over time, as the standard deviation of the difference. A low figure means the portfolio follows the benchmark closely and a high figure means it departs from it.
How it is calculated
Take the portfolio's return minus the benchmark's for each period, which is the active return, and compute the standard deviation of those differences. To annualise a monthly figure, multiply by the square root of 12. If monthly active returns have a standard deviation of 1.0%, annual tracking error is 1.0% x the square root of 12, about 3.5%. The figure is illustrative.
Ex-post and ex-ante
| Type | Based on | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Ex-post (realised) | Past returns | Shows how closely the portfolio actually followed the benchmark |
| Ex-ante (predicted) | Current holdings and a risk model | Estimates how far the portfolio could drift from the benchmark going forward |
Reading the number
- Index funds usually have a very small tracking error, often well under 1%, and the remaining gap comes from fees, cash and trading.
- Active strategies take on tracking error deliberately, since it is the price of any chance of beating the benchmark. Concentrated or small-cap strategies tend to have larger tracking errors.
- It says nothing about whether the difference is good or bad. A strategy can have a low tracking error and trail the benchmark every year.
Related measures
The information ratio divides active return by tracking error. Portfolio construction often sets a tracking-error budget as a limit; see optimization constraints and exposure management. Choosing the benchmark carefully matters, because the same portfolio has a different tracking error against different indices.
Frequently asked questions
What is tracking error?
It is the standard deviation of the difference between a portfolio's returns and its benchmark's returns, usually shown as an annual percentage.
Is a high tracking error bad?
Not by itself. It shows the portfolio differs from the benchmark. Active strategies need some tracking error to have a chance of outperforming, but it also brings the risk of underperforming.
What causes tracking error in an index fund?
Fees, cash holdings, the timing of trades, sampling a subset of the index and the cost of rebalancing.
What is the difference between tracking error and tracking difference?
Tracking difference is the actual gap in return between a fund and its index over a period. Tracking error is the volatility of that gap.