The efficient market hypothesis, or EMH, says that asset prices already reflect available information, so it is hard to consistently earn returns above those justified by risk. It was formalised by Eugene Fama in 1970.
Three forms
| Form | Prices reflect | Implies |
|---|---|---|
| Weak | Past prices and volume | Technical analysis should not work |
| Semi-strong | All public information | Fundamental analysis should not work |
| Strong | All information, including private | Even insiders cannot profit |
What the evidence suggests
- Most active managers fail to beat their benchmark after costs over long periods, in line with efficiency.
- Researchers have documented persistent patterns, such as momentum, value and quality, that are hard to explain by traditional risk measures. See factor investing.
- Markets in emerging economies, with less coverage and lower liquidity, are often considered less efficient than the most-watched developed markets, though the evidence is mixed.
Two ways to read the factors
- Compensation for risk: the premia are fair payment for bearing risks that investors dislike.
- Behavioural or structural mispricing: the premia arise from investor errors or constraints, and could shrink as more capital pursues them.
Why it matters for quants
EMH is the benchmark against which any claim of alpha is judged. If a backtest shows large, easy profits, the first assumption should be an error, such as overfitting or look-ahead bias, before a true inefficiency. A real inefficiency also has limits: costs, capacity and signal decay.
Frequently asked questions
What is the efficient market hypothesis?
It is the theory that asset prices reflect all available information, so consistently earning more than the market's return for the risk taken is difficult.
What are the three forms of the EMH?
Weak form (past prices), semi-strong form (all public information) and strong form (all information including private).
Do factor premiums contradict the EMH?
They are debated. Some see them as compensation for risk, consistent with efficiency, and others as mispricing, which would contradict it.
Is the Indian market efficient?
The evidence is mixed. Less-covered and less liquid segments are often considered less efficient, but opportunities are also harder and costlier to trade.