The investment factor is the finding that companies which expand their assets quickly have tended to earn lower subsequent stock returns than those that invest conservatively. It appears as CMA, conservative minus aggressive, in the Fama-French five-factor model.
How it is measured
Asset growth = (total assets this year - total assets last year) / total assets last year. Cooper, Gulen and Schill (2008) showed that stocks in the highest asset-growth group underperformed those in the lowest.
An illustrative example
| Company A | Company B | |
|---|---|---|
| Assets last year (Rs crore) | 1,000 | 1,000 |
| Assets this year (Rs crore) | 1,400 | 1,050 |
| Asset growth | 40% | 5% |
| Signal | Aggressive investor | Conservative investor |
The numbers are made up. A strategy using this factor would favour B.
Possible explanations
- Rational: firms invest more when their cost of capital is low, so low expected returns follow.
- Behavioural: investors extrapolate growth, and empire-building managers overinvest, so growth is overpaid for.
Cautions
- Asset growth includes acquisitions and one-offs, so it can be noisy.
- Fast-growing businesses are not all poor investments. The factor is an average across many stocks.
- It overlaps with other signals such as growth and the size factor.
- Use point-in-time data: balance-sheet figures are published weeks after the date they describe.
See also Fama-French factor models and factor investing.
Frequently asked questions
What is the investment factor?
It is the tendency of firms with low asset growth to earn higher returns than firms that expand their assets aggressively.
What is CMA in the Fama-French model?
Conservative minus aggressive: the return on low-investment stocks minus high-investment stocks.
Why would high-investment firms earn lower returns?
Explanations include that they face a lower cost of capital, or that investors and managers overpay for growth.
How is asset growth calculated?
The yearly change in total assets divided by the prior year's total assets.