Earnings quality describes how reliably a company's reported profit reflects cash actually earned. Profit that comes mostly from accounting accruals, rather than cash, has tended to be less persistent, and the stocks have tended to underperform.
The accrual ratio
Accrual ratio = (net income - cash flow from operations) / average total assets. A high positive ratio means profit is running ahead of cash.
An illustrative example
| Item (Rs crore) | Company A | Company B |
|---|---|---|
| Net income | 120 | 120 |
| Cash flow from operations | 60 | 130 |
| Average total assets | 1,000 | 1,000 |
| Accrual ratio | (120 - 60) / 1,000 = 6.0% | (120 - 130) / 1,000 = -1.0% |
Both show the same profit, but A's is mostly accounting entries, while B's is backed by cash. The numbers are made up.
The evidence
Sloan (1996) found that stocks with high accruals earned lower returns than stocks with low accruals, because investors seemed to treat accrual and cash earnings as equally persistent when cash earnings last longer. This is often called the accrual anomaly.
Related checks
- Cash flow to net income, and changes in receivables or inventory compared with sales.
- Whether profit growth is matched by operating cash flow growth.
- It forms part of the quality factor and complements the profitability factor.
Cautions
- Fast-growing firms and some industries naturally have high accruals, so compare within sectors.
- The accrual anomaly has weakened since it was published in many markets.
- Use point-in-time data.
Frequently asked questions
What is earnings quality?
It is a measure of how much of a company's reported profit is supported by cash flow and likely to persist.
What is the accrual ratio?
Net income minus cash flow from operations, divided by average total assets.
What is the Sloan accrual anomaly?
The finding that stocks with high accruals tend to underperform stocks with low accruals, because accrual-based profit is less persistent.
Is low earnings quality a red flag?
It can be a warning sign, but accruals also reflect growth and industry differences, so it should be read in context.